Useless ‘He/She Arises Between the Comments’ Facebook Hack Warning

Circulating message warns that there is a ‘new hack on Facebook’ in which the perpetrators ‘arise’ between comments and are thus able to post offensive material that looks like it came from you.

Brief Analysis:
The message is so garbled and misleading that it has no value whatsoever as a security warning and will likely just mislead and confuse Facebook users. There are indeed various security threats that can allow malicious users to hijack your Facebook account and post content in your name. However, this warning does not clearly or accurately describe such threats and copying and pasting it to your wall is therefore counterproductive (Refer to the Detailed Analysis below for more information).

Hey, there I just got this from a good friend! There is a new hack on Facebook. He/She arises between the comments of your contact’s posts, with an offensive comment. It’s really ugly and looks like it came from you. You don’t see him, but your friends do. This can create many offensive misunderstandings. They also post porn pictures. I want to say to all my contacts that if something comes up in my name that is insulting and malicious, it is not my own. Copy and paste on your wall so others will know. Do not share, please


HEADS UP, EVERYONE!!!! In addition to Porno Videos,and photos, there is a new hack on Facebook. Between the comments of your contacts, it includes a hurtful phrase coming from you. It’s very dirty, and it appears that you who have written it. You do not see it, but your friends do. This situation can create many misunderstandings. I would like to say to all my contacts that if something shocking appears, it absolutely does NOT come from me and I would be grateful if you let me know. Thank you very much! Copy and paste. Do not share! You know me!!!

Detailed Analysis:
According to this would-be warning message, there is a new hack on Facebook that you need to be aware of. The warning claims that dastardly hackers can somehow ‘arise between the comments’ of posts made by your Facebook friends and post offensive comments and porn pictures that appear to come from you. It claims that you won’t be able to see these comments but your friends will, thereby causing ‘many offensive misunderstandings’. It asks that you copy and paste the warning on Facebook so that others will be aware of the supposed threat and will understand that any insulting or malicious messages that come up in your name are not really from you.

But, alas, the message is so convoluted, misleading, and inaccurate that it has no value as a security warning and will likely just cause confusion among many Facebook users who encounter it.

Of course, criminals do use various methods to hijack the accounts of unsuspecting Facebook users. They may trick people into installing rogue Facebook apps. Or, they may trick users into revealing their Facebook account login credentials via phishing messages. Or, they may trick people into installing malware that can steal account login information.  If they do manage to take control of your Facebook account using one of these methods, criminals may indeed post ‘offensive’ material – including spam and links to porn, scam, or malware sites – that appears to come from you.

But, this ‘warning’ message does not accurately or clearly describe any of these genuine security threats in any meaningful way. Nor does it provide any information that might help users avoid such traps in the first place.

The message implies that these attackers can magically ‘hack’ into your account at will or somehow inject comments with your name on them in-between other comments on a post. But, even the cleverest criminals cannot just take over a Facebook account whenever they feel the urge. As noted, to successfully hijack an account, they must either trick people into giving up their account login credentials via phishing or malware attacks, or get them to install a rogue app that can post on their behalf.

Criminals may also create a fake account using publicly available images and material stolen from your Facebook Profile and trick some of your friends into accepting friend requests from the fake account. Via this cloned account, they may then be able to post material or add comments that some of your friends might think comes from your real account. But, again, the warning does not accurately describe such cloning attacks. And cloning can not be described as hacking in any case.

The strange wording of the original post suggests that it may have been rather artlessly translated from another language. In fact, the warning is clearly derived from earlier and equally misleading ‘hacker’ warnings that have circulated on Facebook in various forms for years.

A later version corrects some of the strange and unusual grammar found in the original post. But, while the newer version may be more readable, it is still just as useless as a security warning.

It is also worth noting that cybercriminals are usually intent on getting your money or sensitive personal information. Generally speaking, they probably don’t want to hijack your Facebook account just so they can post nasty comments to your friends.

Thus, while its creator may have been well intentioned, posting this garbled ‘warning’ will help nobody.

New Hack on Facebook Bogus Warning

Last updated: October 2, 2016
First published: May 6, 2016
By Brett M. Christensen
About Hoax-Slayer

Pointless Facebook Warning – Hackers Posting Insulting Messages or Sexual Content In Your Name
“Photo U Got Tagged In” Rogue App
‘Your Account Will Disable’ Facebook Phishing Scam
Facebook Cloning Explained